How to Tell if an Article on Google Scholar Is Peer-Reviewed

Google Scholar doesn’t tell you whether an article is peer-reviewed; it has no peer-review label or filter. To check, click through to the article, note the journal name, and look at the journal’s own website for its peer review policy (usually under “About”, “For authors” or “Editorial policies”). You can also search the journal in your library’s databases, many of which have a Peer reviewed filter, or ask a librarian.

Steps to Check an Article

  1. In Google Scholar, read the green line under the title. It shows the authors, the source (journal or publisher) and year.
  2. Click the title to open the article’s page and confirm where it was published.
  3. Go to the journal’s website and look for peer review in its About or policy pages.
  4. Check the article itself for “Received”, “Revised” and “Accepted” dates, which usually indicate review.
  5. Confirm the item type: research article rather than editorial, letter, book review or preprint.
Academic search result showing the journal name and a checklist for confirming peer review
The source line tells you which journal to check.

Does “Cited by” mean it’s peer-reviewed?

No. Citations show influence, not review status.

Signs an Item May Not Be Peer-Reviewed

Item type Peer-reviewed?
Journal research article Usually, if the journal says so
Preprint (arXiv, SSRN and similar servers) Not yet
Thesis or dissertation Reviewed by a committee, not journal peer review
Conference abstract or poster Often lightly or not reviewed
Book chapter Varies by publisher
Editorial, commentary, news No

Other Ways to Confirm

  • Library databases: Many let you tick Peer reviewed or Scholarly journals.
  • Journal directories: Your library may offer a directory that lists whether a journal is refereed.
  • Ask a librarian: They can confirm quickly.

Are open-access articles peer-reviewed?

Many are. Check the journal’s policy the same way.

Tricky Search Results

  • Several versions listed: Click “All versions” and prefer the published journal version over a preprint.
  • Unfamiliar journal: Check that the publisher is established and the journal isn’t on your institution’s list of questionable publishers.
  • Citing it: See MLA format in Google Docs.